(212) 681-1575
Chapter 6: Exploring Your Legal Rights and Options
Many illnesses are idiopathic, meaning of unknown cause; no specific substance is responsible for causing the disease. Mesothelioma is different because its only known cause is exposure to asbestos.
For decades, asbestos companies knew of its dangers, yet they failed to take the simple steps that would have protected tens of thousands of workers and consumers – and their families – from these dangers. Most asbestos companies failed to put warnings on their products or use substitute materials. In fact, many companies went to great pains to keep the known dangers of asbestos secret from both their workers and the public. They put profits before safety.
This bad behavior is why most people with mesothelioma and other asbestos-related diseases file lawsuits – to hold asbestos companies responsible and to get compensation for their injuries.
In this chapter, we explain your rights and options as a victim of asbestos exposure. First, we explain the time limits in your state for filing legal claims for asbestos-related disease. Then we provide advice for finding the right attorney for you and your family. Finally, we provide an overview of the various kinds of financial help that may be available to you so you know which options to discuss with your attorney.
To protect and assert your rights as a mesothelioma patient (or victim of another asbestos-related disease), you have to act quickly after you’ve received your diagnosis.
Every state has placed a time limit, called a statute of limitation, on mesothelioma claims. The clock starts ticking as soon as you receive your initial diagnosis, and if you don’t file your claim within the specified time frame, you lose many of your rights to compensation. In addition, because many people with mesothelioma live less than a year after diagnosis, it’s important to act quickly.
Here are the statutes of limitations for each of the 50 states and the District of Columbia:
| Statute of Limitations Chart | |
| 1 year | Kentucky, Louisiana, Tennessee |
| 2 years | Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Texas, Virginia, West Virginia |
| 3 years | District of Columbia, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Mississippi, Montana, New Hampshire, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Vermont, Washington, Wisconsin |
| 4 years | Florida, Nebraska, Utah, Wyoming |
| 5 years | Missouri |
| 6 years | Maine, North Dakota |
The laws and options surrounding mesothelioma and asbestsos- related disease claims are varied and complex, and you’ll want the help of a qualified and experienced mesothelioma attorney to help you decide which options make the most sense for you and your family.
Find an experienced mesothelioma lawyer who has tried mesothelioma cases in court (gone to verdict) as well as negotiated out-of-court settlements, and is respected nationally as a mesothelioma attorney. It’s also important to hire an attorney who will actually work on your case – not one who will refer your case to another law firm. Many lawyers advertise for mesothelioma cases, but they don’t actually work those cases; instead, they refer you to another lawyer. You should avoid this situation.
To protect your legal rights, you should contact an attorney as soon as possible after you’ve been diagnosed with mesothelioma or any asbestos-related disease. It’s best to choose an attorney or law firm with significant experience in asbestos-related cases, but you also want an attorney you feel comfortable with.
Here are some things to look for when shopping for an attorney:
Your first meeting with an attorney, called an initial consultation, should be free, and the attorney should offer to come to your home. During that first meeting, here are some questions you may want to ask:
Be wary of law firms that send investigators or other non-lawyers to your initial meeting. You are hiring a lawyer, not a professional investigator or marketer – and you should be meeting with a lawyer, not someone who travels around signing up cases.
Relatives may be able to file suit on behalf of someone who has died from mesothelioma or another asbestos-related illness, as long as the claim is filed within the time frame dictated by law. Contact an attorney to find out what your options are.
Belluck & Fox has a national reputation as asbestos and mesothelioma attorneys. We have recovered more than $500 million for our clients with mesothelioma and asbestos-related cancers, and Belluck & Fox has been named one of the top law firms in the United States.
A mesothelioma diagnosis often includes a hefty financial burden. If you don’t already have health insurance, you likely won’t qualify for a new health insurance plan. Even if you have health insurance, your out-of-pocket expenses for doctor’s appointments, tests, treatments, and prescriptions may go up significantly – and some treatments may not be covered at all. You’ll also likely spend more on transportation to and from various appointments and may have to spend more on meals and other travel-related expenses, depending on how far you live from your doctor and/or treatment center. You also may want to participate in experimental treatments, which typically are not covered by insurance.
Most mesothelioma patients have several avenues available to them to help out with the costs associated with their illness. The following sections describe some of these options. Be sure to discuss these with your attorney; in some cases, filing certain claims may limit your rights to other forms of compensation. It’s important to have your mesothelioma lawyer handle all your compensation benefit claims to make sure you’re fully protected.
If you decide to file a lawsuit, your attorney will seek both compensatory and punitive damages. Compensatory damages cover your economic losses – such as medical expenses,
lost income, and any additional costs related to your illness, and your non-economic damages, such as compensation for pain and suffering. Punitive damages are designed to punish the company (or companies) for their negligence or other bad behavior in exposing you to the risks of asbestos. Lawsuits also can recover damages for your spouse’s loss of companionship.
Your attorney will look at several factors in your case, including:
If you’re a smoker and have mesothelioma or another asbestos-related illness, you are still eligible to file a claim. Smoking and asbestos exposure both can cause lung cancer, and these two factors combined increase your risk for developing lung cancer. However, smoking does not cause mesothelioma, asbestosis, or other asbestos-related diseases. If you’ve been diagnosed with one of these diseases, the cause is asbestos exposure and your smoking habits have nothing to do with your illness.
Many companies that manufactured asbestos products have filed for bankruptcy protection to avoid making huge payouts to injured workers and their families. In many cases, bankruptcy judges have ordered the companies to establish trust funds specifically for victims of asbestos-related illnesses. (The nearby sidebar lists some asbestos companies that have declared bankruptcy or are no longer in business as of this writing, but have active trust funds for asbestos claims.) These trust funds pay at a very reduced rate, and the proceeds from these funds aren’t enough to fully compensate you.
Your attorney can help you determine whether you have a legitimate claim against one of the mesothelioma trust funds. These claims must be coordinated with your lawsuit, because they can affect other attempts to win compensation for your illness.
As of 2010, 54 asbestos companies had filed for bankruptcy and established trust funds to deal with claims of asbestos- related diseases. Other companies are awaiting court approval for their bankruptcy trust funds; your attorney will have
up-to-date information.
The following page contains a partial list of asbestos companies with active bankruptcy trust funds.
| Active Bankruptcy Trust Funds | |
| AC&S (ARMSTRONG) | Keene Corp. |
| API, Inc. | Lake Asbestos of Quebec, Ltd. |
| Armstrong World Industries | National Gypsum (GOLD BOND) |
| Babcock and Wilcox Co. | Owens Corning Corp. (KAYLO) |
| Carey Canada, Inc. | Owens Corning Fibreboard |
| Celotex Corp. | Plibrico Co. |
| Combustion Engineering | Porter-Hayden Co. |
| Congoleum Corp. | Raymark Corp./Raytech (RAYBESTOS) |
| Eagle-Picher Industries | Stone and Webster Engineering |
| GAF (DELCO) | T. H. Agriculture and Nutrition, LLC |
| General Motors | Unarco |
| Harbison-Walker | USG (United States Gypsum) Corp. |
| H. K. Porter Co. | Western MacArthur/Western Asbestos |
| Johns-Manville Corp. (TRANSITE) | W.R. Grace |
Class action lawsuits involve a large group of people who suffer similar injuries or wrongdoing at the hands of the same defendant(s). Class action lawsuits aren’t used in mesothelioma and asbestos cases. Class action suits most often are settled out of court and therefore often appeal to people who don’t want to go to trial. However, because of the large number of claimants (those suing for damages), settlements in these cases are typically based on the broadest interests of the class. Individual circumstances that may warrant a larger settlement amount aren’t considered in class action cases.
The lack of consideration for individual circumstances is the main reason that the U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that class action lawsuits aren’t appropriate for asbestos cases. People who are exposed to asbestos have widely differing circum- stances, including different exposure levels, different ages, different diseases, and different medical treatment. Such variety makes it virtually impossible to craft a class action settlement that would be fair to every member of the class.
Depending on your circumstances, you may be eligible to receive other kinds of assistance to help you with the financial impact of your illness. You should discuss these options with your attorney, who can tell you more about the process of applying for these forms of assistance and the impact such applications may have on your case.